When it comes to measuring dissolved oxygen in water, choosing the right device can greatly impact your results and efficiency. This article delves into a comparative analysis of two prominent dissolved oxygen meters: the Portable Dissolved Oxygen Meter YR06380 from Kalstein and the Dissolved Oxygen Meter DO210 from Extech. Both devices are designed for portability and accuracy, yet they each offer unique features that cater to different user needs.
The Kalstein Portable Dissolved Oxygen Meter YR06380 is known for its remarkable precision and versatile applications. This meter is ideal for various settings like environmental water testing, laboratory analysis, and wastewater treatment facilities. On the other hand, the Extech DO210 is appreciated for its user-friendly design and reliable performance, suitable for educational purposes and simple field tests.
| Feature | Kalstein YR06380 | Extech DO210 |
|---|---|---|
| Measurement Range | 0.0 to 20.0 mg/L | 0.0 to 20.0 mg/L |
| Accuracy | ± 0.1 mg/L | ± 0.4 mg/L |
| Temperature Compensation | Automatic | Manual |
| Display Type | LCD | LCD |
| Battery Life | 200 hours | 100 hours |
How They Work
The Kalstein YR06380 operates by utilizing electrochemical sensors to determine the amount of dissolved oxygen in a water sample. This method includes a probe that absorbs oxygen and transforms the information into an electrical current, showing the results on the device’s display.
The Extech DO210 functions similarly but incorporates a simpler manual calibration process. This can be advantageous in scenarios where basic functionality and ease of use are more valued than precision and advanced features.
Use Case
Both devices serve the purpose of measuring dissolved oxygen with a focus on portability and accuracy. The Kalstein YR06380’s advanced sensors and automatic temperature compensation make it suitable for precise scientific research, while the Extech DO210 is often used in educational environments where ease of use is critical.
Types
Dissolved oxygen meters can generally be classified into three types: portable, benchtop, and online/digital. Both the Kalstein YR06380 and Extech DO210 fall into the portable category, designed for field use and accessible measurements.
Market Price
The Kalstein YR06380 is competitively priced, offering advanced features for accurate scientific research. It typically ranges from $300 to $500, depending on additional features and supplier quotes. In contrast, the Extech DO210 is priced more towards users who require basic functionality, with prices ranging from $150 to $250.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do the sensors last?
The sensor life varies depending on usage and maintenance, but typically, sensors on both devices can last several years with proper care.
Is calibration needed before every use?
Both devices require calibration to ensure accuracy. The Kalstein YR06380 supports automatic calibration, while the Extech DO210 involves a manual process.
Advantages and Disadvantages
The Kalstein YR06380 has a significant edge with its high accuracy, automatic temperature compensation, and long battery life, making it perfect for precise and extended field study. However, it may come at a higher initial cost, justified by its advanced functionality.
The Extech DO210, while more affordable, may lack the precision and convenience of automatic features, making it more suited for basic educational applications.
Product Usage in the Field
In practical scenarios, the Kalstein YR06380 excels in environments requiring consistent monitoring and high accuracy, such as marine biology or aquaculture. Its robust design and extended battery life make it a reliable choice for prolonged fieldwork.
Meanwhile, the Extech DO210’s straightforward setup makes it optimal for classroom demonstrations or brief field visits where fundamental readings suffice.
Recommendations
For users requiring thorough and reliable oxygen level readings, the Kalstein YR06380 is recommended due to its precision and durability. Regular calibration and proper maintenance will ensure its longevity and accuracy. It is highly advised for researchers and professionals in need of advanced data.
The Extech DO210 is recommended for users seeking a cost-effective solution where moderate accuracy and simplicity are sufficient, such as educational settings or simple field tests. Its ease of use and affordability make it a practical choice for beginners.
If you’re in search of a blend of innovation and quality, you’ve come to the right place. At Kalstein, we offer the luxury of exploring our exclusive catalog of laboratory equipment. We manufacture each piece with a level of excellence. Our online purchasing channels, intuitive and agile, are designed for your convenience, ensuring the most friendly prices. Don’t hesitate any longer, we bring science to life, it’s time to become part of our community. https://kalstein.se/product/portable-dissolved-oxygen-meter-yr06380/.